Trash-Man-1's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Purple Gotham Skies]

Very good solid work.

This is very good indeed. It sure does have that gotham feeling. Very good clean mixing as well. I really like the solid percussion in this, and it goes well with the strings. Everything is also panned very well, adding to the solidness of this song.

Great work.

S3C responds:

thank you!

[Longing [pianopiece]]

Great performance

Great performance. I wish it were a little longer, but oh well, its good for what you have. Very moving piece.

Ambrossys responds:

Glad you liked it =) I wanted it short. But yea, you're right, it could have been longer ;)

[Idea 211]

Really solid performance

Very good piano work there. It sounds so crisp and clean and upfront. The strings are super nicely done as well.

Beautiful work.

ErikMcClure responds:

Thanks a bunch :D

[Cosmic Witch Hunter]

Very good solid work.

I really like the intro as well. Very nice work on those guitars. The rain is a little weird, but I guess it fits.

Once it gets going, it's pretty nice, though maybe the mixing needs just a slight amount of work once it gets heavy, since it seems to drop in volume and doesn't have that punch in the face that it should after an ambient intro.

Your performance is great, so please don't get me wrong.

Very nice work.

[Differentiae]

Pretty nice stuff man.

I really like this. It makes me think of a story about vampires for some reason. I don't think it's to slow or too fast. I think it's just right and gets a good mood across. Really nice mixture of sounds going on. I really like that piano.

Piano is kinda loud at 2 mins, may want to lower it just a tad. Please note that this is only a minor issue, and it may just be my taste.

Great work.

Kirbyfemur responds:

Yeah i can see where it might be too loud, that was just trying to add a little difference in the dynamics, Buuut may have had that to loud. But since this isn't a killer problem i'm probably not going to mess with it. But thank you for your input and review. =3

[Frozen Melody]

PRetty good stuff

I really liked what I heard.

Anyway, really solid composition here. I think the drums are fine as they are and the intro is just fine. I like the spots where it takes a break from the drums as it helps give a different feel for those parts.

smilingpig67 responds:

Thanks~

[Run for your life (Battle)]

very solid

It's pretty good. The part near the end is just a little sour at parts, and because it's the only part that has those sour notes, it seems out of place. I would suggest to change it to non sour notes there so it fits. That's pretty much all I have to suggest. Good job.

[Defiled Temple (Final Boss)]

A little short

For a final boss, this is rather short. You got it starting good, but what you have is pretty much for the intro to the boss, or like the part before the final boss as he's forming. We need some more action and intensity to feel like its a boss. Good stuff so far though. Also, the mixing is rather quiet and it needs to be more upfront.

Charleon responds:

Hmm, you're right, it's a little bit quiet.. I wonder where i errored in the mastering process :/ , as for the short part: yes its short, it's simply a concept for a final boss at this stage, if it gets voted through, I can continue on it. Thanks for pointing things out =)

[Super Beata]

Quite fun.

Who on earth is rating all these new things so low... This is at least a 4 star..

Anyway, cool stuff. Pretty funky indeed. My only suggestion would be a few of the percussion seem odd and out of place for this kind of music. Also later on it struggles just a tad, so it could use some filler stuff and an overall cleaning up so things are tighter in those rough spots.