Trash-Man-1's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Two Shots]

Really solid production

I can't find anything wrong with this production-wise. It's just that solid. Very well made song. I really like the intro to this. All I suggest is maybe vary it up in each of the main parts, because it kinda drags on for each one.

At about 2 mins, it gets a little sour when you mix that 3rd part with the 2md part for a second there. You may want to reconsider that transition, as it's not very smooth.

8/10
4/5

Methreee responds:

hey cool thanks a lot. i'll definitely look that over and i appreiciate you taking the time to point that out...

[Summer Sun - full]

Pretty nice.

It's pretty nice. Usually the 0 bombers are just biased jerks who only listen to a specific genre. Don't let the score bother you. Just go by what you get in your reviews. Get more people to listen to your music and link them here.

Anyway, I really like the song, its nice and full sounding. Maybe a little on the repettitive side and maybe I would suggest to get to new ideas just a little sooner. I know things need to be held out in this genre, but if you hold it out too long without something changing, it just gets a little bland.. Don't worry this is very minor.

8/10
4/5

Geckone responds:

Thanks for advice. I would keep that in mind.

I think I could fix this repeatability, if i get enough time. Anyway thanks for positive review.

[[Pixz.] Whispering Ambience]

Good, but needs more.

Its nice sounding, I just feel it needs more variation, especially in the percussion.

Good sound though.

iPixzel responds:

Thanks advice man

[<Earths> Paradise]

Good stuff.

I really like the sound the percussion has the most.

Other thoughts are:

Maybe change that harmonic sound to another instrument at points in the song so that it's not the same thing. Maybe also make a prominent Melody so things are less repetitive.

Good song.

Boogerblaster1690 responds:

ty for the feedback trash-man and i totally hear what ur saying. i used alot of glass flute on that, but i wasnt really aiming at something twisting and turning but more on the lines of a simple loop. i see what ur saying though and ty for the feedback again. =D

[Left Out]

GOod, but rather short.

Make this longer, its really good what you have so far, but it's too short.

Great stuff for what you have so far. Solid mixing.

joshuaskillsrobles responds:

Yeah this was originally a song, but i couldnt come up with the rest so i left it a loop.

[Purple Gotham Skies]

Very good solid work.

This is very good indeed. It sure does have that gotham feeling. Very good clean mixing as well. I really like the solid percussion in this, and it goes well with the strings. Everything is also panned very well, adding to the solidness of this song.

Great work.

S3C responds:

thank you!

[Longing [pianopiece]]

Great performance

Great performance. I wish it were a little longer, but oh well, its good for what you have. Very moving piece.

Ambrossys responds:

Glad you liked it =) I wanted it short. But yea, you're right, it could have been longer ;)

[Idea 211]

Really solid performance

Very good piano work there. It sounds so crisp and clean and upfront. The strings are super nicely done as well.

Beautiful work.

ErikMcClure responds:

Thanks a bunch :D

[Differentiae]

Pretty nice stuff man.

I really like this. It makes me think of a story about vampires for some reason. I don't think it's to slow or too fast. I think it's just right and gets a good mood across. Really nice mixture of sounds going on. I really like that piano.

Piano is kinda loud at 2 mins, may want to lower it just a tad. Please note that this is only a minor issue, and it may just be my taste.

Great work.

Kirbyfemur responds:

Yeah i can see where it might be too loud, that was just trying to add a little difference in the dynamics, Buuut may have had that to loud. But since this isn't a killer problem i'm probably not going to mess with it. But thank you for your input and review. =3

[Frozen Melody]

PRetty good stuff

I really liked what I heard.

Anyway, really solid composition here. I think the drums are fine as they are and the intro is just fine. I like the spots where it takes a break from the drums as it helps give a different feel for those parts.

smilingpig67 responds:

Thanks~