00:00
00:00
Trash-Man-1

136 Art Reviews

46 w/ Responses

4 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

One problem.

Today is Sunday.

Merol responds:

I have to update my calendar.

Pretty much all of what was already said.

I pretty much would say all of what has already been said, which by the way, was not in anyway overly cruel (this aimed at other viewers and not you, the author), because it was just a list of what the person sees wrong, which is true.

Try being more balanced in colors, and try to avoid large anatomical mistakes, as well as attention to detail in the foreground to make it pop forward more. Right now the drawing looks very flat due to everything having the same level of detail which only drops off when we go all the way to the background starting at the other snowman.

Your shadowing and highlighting also needs a lot of work, as most of it just doesn't make sense and it's probably best to find a new approach, or greatly refine the one you have. The choice is yours, but for now it just doesn't really work and only adds to the flat appearance.

And as for viewers, if you don't agree with another person, just accept it, don't consider them as anything, otherwise you only drop to their "assumed" level.

pretty good

For 3d, you seem to have dodged all the usual creepiness it leaves behind when people use it. I comment you for that, because it is very rare for something to look as natural as this picture does when you use 3d.

Typical

Typical anime usual bland stuff drawn by a person who probably doesn't even care about their own family, and would walk all over them in order to progress in life in an attempt at furthering their greedy artwork habit.

Ashe-Marbury responds:

And you're somebody who speaks as if you've already experienced all of the above and are attempting to troll because you have nothing else better to do except to try and bring others down with you. You're a pathetic excuse for a human being and I -know- I'm better than you because of who you are - you expressed that in your stupid approach. Shut up. Get a life. Go bother somebody else - and if you're going to attack someone, at least attack them when you actually have the facts. Thank you. :)

Yep it's offical. All you do is copy

http://www.spanishcalibur.com/galeria/So uls/Talim.jpg (take out the space in souls)

Once again, a quick google has found that all you did was copy. This time you barely changed anything.

Show me something original in your fanart, and I will actually enjoy it. Just copy and not really be original, and I will just give the credit completely to the original creator of the character..

This is to be expected though, as I know your kind.

Looks an awful lot like this one...

http://harufreak.deviantart.com/a rt/FFXII-Penelo-136080763 (take out the space in art)

Looks an awful lot like that one I was able to google in 2 seconds.

Please, for the love of god, try to be original and stop copying other people. It's very rude to the person who actually came up with the pose. Minor changes in arms and facial expressions are not going to hide the fact that you did this.

I'm am almost positive I can find the original picture if I look up every last one of your drawings.

In fanart, I'd rater see it be as original as possible, which means no copying of poses. The less copying, the better, seeing as it's already just fanart and that is why you are better of being as original as possible, rather than just copying something and only making a few slight changes in order to hide this fact.

Sev4 responds:

Okay. I read your comments, thanks for sharing your (repetitious) opinion.
I've never seen this picture before working on mine.
I could explain the purpose of my work on that kind of pictures and what they're bringing to me, but I don't think you actually care
so, whatever...

Just a direct copy of the pose

Like your Midna, you have just directly copied the official artwork, this time making very very minor changes, mainly in just the face and slightly longer hair.

I very much frown upon fanart when it only just copies the official artwork and is not in any way original.

Nicely drawn, but that really is not much to say when you copy stuff.

All you did was copy a pose, and...

That's all you did. You copied this pose:

http://wantmidnaback.com/images/g allery/screenshots/slides/Official%20Chuckling%20Midna.html (take out the space in gallery to view that link).

As nice as it is drawn. I would rather have seen it not be such a direct copy of the pose with only minor details like the arms position and the facial expression being changed.

I also noticed you have done this in some other drawings as well, like your Eiko drawing. This is a typical trick a lot of anime artists do to get their quick ticket to fame.

Try again, and maybe next time don't directly copy a pose.

Pretty good

It's some pretty good stuff here. Very good use of colors and concept.

However, I must mention that it appears to use some rather wasted space, thus causing the focus to be less of the characters, and more of what is around them. I feel the image would just come across better if you cropped it just a little so that the focus is more on the characters.

Keep in mind, this is a minor issue, and was pretty much the only slight thing I could find to pick at.

Interesting approach

It's almost like a Mii version of the character. At least, it makes me think of that anyway. Never played that game, but I've seen enough fan art to know who the character is, and I like your approach on it.

Good stuff.

I like to compose music. I also like to draw.

Male

Joined on 7/28/05

Level:
35
Exp Points:
12,898 / 13,600
Exp Rank:
2,134
Vote Power:
7.60 votes
Rank:
Corporal
Global Rank:
2,183
Blams:
726
Saves:
3,324
B/P Bonus:
22%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
806